Tuesday, February 14, 2017

Argumentative Essay - Two Points of View

"What hopes and fears did Americans have about the arrival of new immigrants into our country in the 1900's compared to the hopes and fears that are evident in today's current events over immigration? 

Sixth graders have been asking this essential question and using their technology skills to help them research the problems and communicate the answers they have found into an argumentative essay that shows two points of view. They used a gaming program that immersed them into a historical setting as a fourteen year old, Jewish girl who emigrated from Russia in 1903.  The game promoted the idea that assuming the roll of a peer from that time period would develop a more personal and meaningful connection with history.
http://www.mission-us.org

Another website, zoomin.edc.org, was used to help guide the writing process.  Students were given original documents from the beginning of the 20th century and then guided through the evidence found in them that supported different points of view.


Finally, students summarized current news articles over the travel ban and compared the reasoning behind the ban to the hopes and fears that present day Americans have. 


No comments:

Post a Comment